Shetland's
FIRST daily
newspaper

The Shetland News - Shetland's Daily Internet News Magazine

Read all
around the
world, daily

Police states are unsafe

 

19 January, 2008

I FEEL sorry for folk like Ross Smith who glibly accept - nay, eagerly await - all the rules, regulations, enhanced security measures, greater ID requirements and photos, in the belief that it makes them safer when travelling, buying over the internet, applying for a driving licence/passport or all the other transactions in life.

It is not only dangerous but irresponsible as well, to believe that the more complicated the system gets, the more (so called) secure systems become, the more information kept on file/database etc, the safer things are. I can only assume Ross doesn't read or watch the news because in recent months alone there have been several very high profile cases of lost (so called) secure personal data by banks, private companies and government agencies resulting in potentially very serious circumstances for the millions of folk involved.
On a daily basis hundreds of folk have their identities stolen or duplicated and their finances raided, bank and credit card accounts fraudulently accessed etc.

If Ross thinks a photo along with more personal information on a computer somewhere gives him more safety or security then that's his choice, but I don't trust any of it and the evidence supports my stance on this as we have more identity theft and financial fraud now than ever, despite more security, information and photographs.

As to the P&O thing, I might hark back to the past but the lessons of life teach us that progress for progress' sake is utter folly, doesn't often give greatly improved benefits and only guarantees the need sometimes to reinvent the wheel or to seek a consultant to take it all to bits and start again, which is usually a complete waste of time and money. The P&O set up wasn't broken and didn't need fixing.It just needed some financial help to build new ships just like NorthLink got. P&O knew what they were doing and had a good track record, so we got NorthLink who could do it all cheaper and better, but look how the Scottish Government had to bail them out with millions of pounds because they got their sums ridiculously wrong.

As to drink driving, I put my hand up to being guilty of this. I was a first offender after a serious emotional situation, it was inexcusable and I am ashamed of myself. So I certainly do not advocate drink driving and the
suggestion that shops should be broken into because they are closed is just plain silly. Does Ross think that photo ID cards would stop drink drivers, shop lifters and all other troublesome people? Oh! And how would a photo stop freeloaders coming to Shetland for an easy life when we live in the EU with free right to work and travel anywhere in the EU? Does a freeloader have a certain facial type easily recognised in an ID photo? How would a photo ID card stop folk with pockets full of drugs?

Wake up Ross. Your police state with photo ID cards would not make things safer at all. It never has and it never will.

Vic Thomas
Hoswick
Shetland
vic.thomas@btopenworld.com

 

Advertisements

Advertise with The Shetland News

 
ARCHIVE
HOME

Most recent update - Friday, 26 February 2010 11:43

All content Copyright © 2003-2010 Shetland News Agency
This website is financed entirely privately, with no grants, subsidies or public money

Please see our disclaimer
SHETLAND NEWS
HOME